Skip to main content

The Night Watch by Sarah Waters #inbetweeny

Well what a book! I don't quite know how to review The Night Watch without revealing too much of the story line. This isn't a plot based book as such and so to gloss over what little there is in this blog might take something away from the reader which I don't want to do.

The book was lent to me from a friend (who has an excellent blog by the way: but to be honest I didn't really fancy it from the blurb which I thought was the weakest part of the book. However I had previously read two of Waters' books (Tipping the Velvet and the excellent Fingersmith) and with it being strongly recommended I set to work.

The book skips about in London during the second world war and is centred around 3 women and 1 man. It took my a while to get to grips with everyone and it was strange to have a man interspersed within the women's stories. However Duncan's story fitted into the overreaching arc of the book and provided an interesting angle. Having read Tipping the Velvet and Fingersmith I should have known what to expect with The Night Watch however the theme set to the back drop of the war surprised me and wasn't hinted at in the blurb.

I initially found the book slow especially, surprisingly, compared to the recently read Vanity Fair which was almost double in length. Typical of Waters were the complicated characters repeating mistakes and destined to be unhappy by their own making. It was a tad graphic in places but then Waters often is and I found myself slowly warming to the book as it progressed (or should that be regressed?)

I loved the contrast between Helen's relationship in the first part of the story compared to the second. I felt retrospectively angry at Viv in the first part of the book when reading the second and similarly sympathetic to Kay. To totally change a readers perspective takes skill and Waters excellent writing pulled it off brilliantly. 

The topsy turvy timeframe really added an extra dimension to the prose lead book. It was only as I approached the last 50 or so pages that I realised the story line wouldn't be coming to an 'end' and I liked the book more because of it. I wouldn't say it is as good as Fingersmith but it is a grower and I can't wait to discuss it at book club with people who have read it where I won't have to worry about giving away too much. Read it if you want to find out more! 


Popular posts from this blog

The Continuity Girl by Patrick Kincaid #BlogTour

When this little beauty arrived through my letterbox my 9 year old picked it up and said "Mummy it looks like an old strip of film but made to look like the Loch Ness Monster". That was the cover certainly nailed and being a previous media studies student that sort of thing appeals to me.

The book was primarily set in the Highlands and being a frequent holiday-er to those parts I also appreciated the location. Set around the discovery of an uncut version of a real film (The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes) it flits between the 1969 film shoot and present day London. The concept reminded me of Beautiful Ruins (one of my favourite reads of the year) and I of course had to immediately Google the film and now have developed an urge to read Conan Doyle's back catalogue.

I really liked Jim the marine biologist looking for proof the Loch Ness Monster did(n't?) exist. The book is billed as a romantic comedy and it was different reading this type of book from a male's per…

This Is Going To Hurt by Adam Kay, Secret Diaries of a Junior Doctor #BookOfTheMonth

This was one of a large selection put forward as contenders for July's #BookOfTheMonth and knowing it was for sale in Sainsburys not one, not two, not three but FOUR members of the group legged it there after the meeting to purchase a copy.

This Is Going To Hurt is a no-holds barred account of one junior doctor’s time on the front line of the NHS. Kay, being the said doctor, excellently explained the medical jargon not least by adding some of the best footnotes ever (Dick Fan Dyke). I understand on for e-readers these may have been removed to the back of the book which I imagine would greatly affect the reading experience.

I was surprised by the amount I learnt but make no mistake, a medical text book this is not. The anecdotes had strong humour and Kay didn't hold back, although I did question a particular sentence on page 63 (well in my copy anyway).

I cringed (the lamppost) almost as much as I laughed yet overall it was a heartbreaking account of how close to breaking point…

Alice by Christina Henry #BookOfTheMonth

I have wanted to read Alice for ages stumbling across it on Twitter and purchasing Lost Boy, the Peter Pan reworking, at the same time.

I mention reworking but sequeal to Alice in Wonderland is probably a more accurate description of Henry's tale. I thought it a very clever idea - a tea party gone wrong leaving Alice mentally disturbed/traumatised by what has happened to her. The White Rabbit is present as is the Cheshire Cat , although as evil gang lords there is little to liken them to Disney's interpretation of the Carroll classic.

Whereas I loved the concept, I thought the book floundered in the actual telling of the story. There seemed to be a lot of walking around interspersed with very brutal, descriptive passages. Some very powerful scenes (particularly the Alice/Hatcher scene at his grandmother's house upon their escape) followed by some very weak sections. The villains were portrayed as pure evil yet their confrontations with Alice and Hatcher were tame in compar…