Skip to main content

Her Fearful Symmetry - Audrey Niffenegger

It took me a long time to brave this book as I loved The Time Travellers Wife and thought that nothing could compare so why bother? Nevertheless it found its way under my bed and then into my next to read and low and behold before I knew what I was doing I had suggested it as Novembers book.

The book got off to a good start. I loved Martins storey witnessing him and his wifes struggle with his OCD (could have read a whole storey about this alone) and even Elspeth as a ghost didn’t put me off (The Time Travellers Wife had a husband who travelled randomly through time and that had me in tears so a little ghost wasn’t going to put me off)

There were also some really good moments - Elspeth going to hide/sulk in the drawer and then seeking warmth from the TV – traditionally seen as being so cold and causing lack of communication

I also loved reading about the cemetery and now want to go!

Unfortunately that’s where the plus points ended and not just for me but for all of the group.

We thought the twins were weak characters. I understood what Niffeneger was trying to impress on us by the twins needing to separate and how Valentina found it suffocating however this was only grasped at here and there and Valentina’s chosen solution was extreme, unforeseen and silly really. She wasn’t suicidal and although there might have been more going on in the back ground (Julia’s black eye) the reader wasn’t given enough to make the decision believable.

The whole love triangle was also unbelievable or was that just Robert and Valentina and what was the point of Jessica, what did she add to the storey?

The diaries that could have revealed I feel a much more explosive secret were again, like Valentina’s decision, unbelievable and confusing. We all totally lost track about which twin was who and weren’t clear even when we were all sat down talking about it ‘So Elspeth who was really Edie and was Valentinas real mother took over Valentinas dead body and then gave birth?’ Silly sentence right?

The ending felt like Niffeneger realised her word count was up and had to tie all lose ends up quickly which was done by giving everyone as far as possible a sugar coated happy ending. The twins dad knew all along of the twin switch so no big drama there, Julia couldn’t be with Martin so conveniently in walks Martins son who we are expected to think is ok because he is Martins son despite the fact he had not been around to support his father at all through the storey. Martin who hadn’t left his landing in more than a year upped, left and travelled all the way to Amsterdam in one fell swoop to live a supposedly happy and cured life with his wife. It was all just far fetched, unbelievable and convenient.

There were talking points - why did Robert leave at the end? One member of the group pointed out that Robert had been left by his father when he was young so this was history repeating itself or another example of symmetry that was evident throughout the book. Why did Elspeth prevent Edie and husband from entering the flat? Was it spite to illustrate even early on her nasty character? Was Elspeth always going to go back into Valentinas body or was it just because she realised she couldn’t keep Valentina to herself? You were left with the feeling that if there had just been more word court and a bit more thought a good book could have been unearthed.

It wasn’t though and we ended up gave it a 5. The verdict was pretty unanimous which is unusual for our group. There is nearly always at least one loan voice who dissents from the pack but we overwhelmingly all liked the beginning then thought it just became silly. Do read Niffenegger but make sure it’s the Time Travellers Wife rather than this one.

Question of the month – What’s your favourite Ghost Storey?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Lock down book club - books from a different country

So we continued with the Zoom version of book club this month and it was lovely to see so many of us tackle it. The theme was books set in a different country (if you can't travel, let a book take you).  I read The Accident on the A35 by Graeme Macrae Burnet, a detective story with an element of tricksy fiction set in France. I really enjoyed it and you can read my full review here. We travelled to America a couple of times most interestingly to see whether Hilary Clinton (or Bill for that fact) would have made President if they had not got married. Rodham by Curtis Sittenfeld is out in hardback now. Norway was a popular spot - Norwegian Nights by Derek B Miller about a retired american marine who moves to Norway and intervenes to save a young boys life sounded interesting. So much so that at least one member of the group has gone on to buy the first in the series, American By Day. We even made it as far as Japan and Botswana (and discovered a Scottish connection for Alexander McCa

The Hunting Party by Lucy Foley

"In a remote hunting lodge, deep in the Scottish wilderness, old friends gather for New Year. The beautiful one The golden couple The volatile one The new parents The quiet one The city boy The outsider The victim. Not an accident – a murder among friends." We had all read the book and all agreed we hadn't really read a book where the victim was revealed at the same time as the murderer. We liked this and found it a definite page turner. The victim not being revealed so late however meant that everyone had to, theoretically, be capable of wanting to murder everyone else which made for a whole host of not nice characters. We all struggled with the characters in someway. We didn't like them. There were too many. They were too self-centered, too two dimensional. Not liking the characters often means we don't like the book and there is no denying it was definitely a hindrance. A few of the group also commented on a plot hole or two. When exactly did

Lock down book club - autobiographies

After what felt like 13 million weeks in lock down we attempted to conduct our first online meeting via Zoom. We chose a broad theme of 'autobiographies' to give as many of us as possible a chance at obtaining a book without too much difficulty. I actually didn't have an autobiography on my shelf and so borrowed The Last American Man by Elizabeth Gilbert. The book was all about raccoon eating, teepee living, deer skin wearing Eustace Conway. He has lived a fascinating life and Gilbert had carried out interviews with a wide range of friends and family but I found the lack of pictures puzzling. You gotta have pictures in an autobiography. The group had chosen autobiographies from a real wide range of people. Partly due to availability, partly due to differing interests. We had Gok Wan and his troubled childhood as a non white gay person. Louis XIV (the Sun King) and his debauched court and two Michelle Obamas one of which was given up on. I think the broad topic made fo