Skip to main content

Double Trouble!!

New Year, new book club – we had to review TWO books this time which is a first and at first a tall order (or so I thought). However even when working right up until Christmas Eve and having more Christmas parties than you could shake a stick at, by New Year I had read them both and was in fact on my second post book club book(s) read. Trueman Capote in Cold Blood and Dark Fire CJ Sansom if you must know.

The Silent Wife – ASA Harrison was first on my list as I managed to sneak it in with the weekly shop at ASDA.

I read this book super quickly as I found Harrison had an uncanny knack of getting me to read the next chapter without me even noticing. Never the less I found the book dragged and wanted the plot to move on quicker.

I didn’t like any of the characters even Jodi which confused me. On the face of it why wouldn’t I like Jodi – a badly wronged wife who was having her home taken away from her by her cheating husband who had gotten a girl half her age pregnant? I should have been cheering for Todd to die and willing Natasha/Natalie (can’t remember her name) to get her comeuppance. Yet I didn’t really care whether Todd went back to Jodi or whether Jodi tried to crush more sleeping pills into his tea.

Ironically Jodi wanted to avoid being like her mother by not marrying and not having children but she missed once crucial point - financial independence. In the end she ended up just like her mother - not saying anything, and look at damage she caused by not saying anything! Not just to her marriage but to her brother as well.

What was the whole thing with the hives/HIV? It had potential to be another twist in the tail – hurt Jodi even further, make it look as though Todd killed himself when he found out he was HIV positive instead of being murdered, even making it look like Natalie/Natasha killed him or had cheated on him and become infected yet it petered out to nothing.

I did skim read parts, thought it took a long time to come to Todds departure and then found the ending all too easily tied up.

The Group had a couple of interesting points to add to the above. One lady in particular thought that perhaps Jodi had killed Todd however the police couldn’t pin it on her and Dean who fit the bill took the cop for it. It was an interpretation I hadn’t thought of at the time but looking back it fit with Jodi backtracking from the whole situation stating she would have turned herself in and therefore she was really a good person. It was Jodi’s way of protecting herself and keeping things on a surface level that she did very successfully throughout the whole book. Her friends were seen on a rota system, her family not kept in contact with, everyone was kept at a distance including Todd. This was reiterated by the fact she only took on clients that had a certain level of mental illness – nothing that would push her or cause her emotional distress. She didn’t really seem to be close to anything. Looking at it from this point of view the book was sad in some ways as she entered into the relationship with Todd as seemingly relatively sane, he had no money, he adored her and asked her several times to marry her. Where did it go wrong?

I think I definitely got more out of the book from the book club than I did actually reading it and whereas usually I love finding different interpretations and meanings by the time of the meeting I had gone a bit past the point of caring so kept my score at a 6. The group overall gave it a 5.5. It varied massively in range from 10-4 so massively split the group.



Next on the list was Death Comes to Pemberley by PJ James a follow on from Pride and Prejudice (shock horror) that I really fancied reading. Now we have reviewed this type of thing before – Horowitz – Sherlock – House of Silk - which faired fairly so-so however P&P was legendary amongst our circle (my mum at least) so it would be interesting to see how it faired amongst diehard fans.

I liked the way it recapped over Pride and Prejudice so that at least readers who had not come across the story before (and there are some) knew who was who and what was going on. This carried on throughout the book and was required as James relied very heavily on past events to carry the story (not a criticism why wouldn’t you with P&P?)

The book is what you would expect in many ways, very English, polite society, ladies and gentleman which again I really liked. Am I a sucker for a good old English yarn? Northanger Abbey, Little Village School. Interesting hadn’t thought about that before.

I’m pleased she didn’t stray too far from where Austin left the characters – there was no killing off Jane or something equally as ludicrous, which is a good thing as nobody wanted to see Darcy dead or such like (Helen Fielding take note!) The book seemed to be quite warmly received by the group and when questioned seem to pick this as the main reason. They loved P&P and wanted a continuation of it without breaking away from the happy ending Austin had provided. The concept therefore of a murder mystery involving the characters but in no way putting them at risk was a good one.

Ignoring P&P, in terms of murder mysteries I didn’t find it the greatest, which is a surprise considering the author. I didn’t guess the killer but then how were we supposed to? (won’t comment more on this point in case you haven’t read it!). I also found there was too much going over old ground – the trial seemed to just rehash all that we had already discovered first hand. This was in addition to the substantial references to P&P. I wanted to read a new book not an edited version of the first which it sometimes felt like. I feel the word count could have been used to develop the mystery part of the book more as most of us approached the book with prior knowledge of the characters anyway.

I also found the book lacked the humour that P&P had. There were glimpses - the recap where town gossips decided that Elizabeth had set out to capture Darcy right from the moment she first clapped eyes on him but not enough for me. Yes I know it was a murder mystery and therefore humour would be short on the ground but I wanted more and I was longing for Mrs Bennett to make an appearance which she never did.

So, a very English, slightly disappointing murder mystery with one or two familiar names and faces along the way. But hats off to James she is one very brave lady to mess with Austin!

I gave it a 7 and the group gave it 7.5, quite even scores all round.

PS The group generally didn’t seem to like the TV version of the book the main reason being that the actor playing Darcy just wasn’t Darcy. Interestingly nobody picked this as a fault with the book thinking that James captured Darcy really well.


Next book The Rosie Project by Graeme Simsion.


Question of the month – As mentioned above James isn’t the first to take on a well-loved book/author/character and give it their own spin. Bond, Sherlock, Peterpan. Are they automatically going to fail or do they have a place in their own right? Any good examples?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Lock down book club - books from a different country

So we continued with the Zoom version of book club this month and it was lovely to see so many of us tackle it. The theme was books set in a different country (if you can't travel, let a book take you).  I read The Accident on the A35 by Graeme Macrae Burnet, a detective story with an element of tricksy fiction set in France. I really enjoyed it and you can read my full review here. We travelled to America a couple of times most interestingly to see whether Hilary Clinton (or Bill for that fact) would have made President if they had not got married. Rodham by Curtis Sittenfeld is out in hardback now. Norway was a popular spot - Norwegian Nights by Derek B Miller about a retired american marine who moves to Norway and intervenes to save a young boys life sounded interesting. So much so that at least one member of the group has gone on to buy the first in the series, American By Day. We even made it as far as Japan and Botswana (and discovered a Scottish connection for Alexander McCa

The Hunting Party by Lucy Foley

"In a remote hunting lodge, deep in the Scottish wilderness, old friends gather for New Year. The beautiful one The golden couple The volatile one The new parents The quiet one The city boy The outsider The victim. Not an accident – a murder among friends." We had all read the book and all agreed we hadn't really read a book where the victim was revealed at the same time as the murderer. We liked this and found it a definite page turner. The victim not being revealed so late however meant that everyone had to, theoretically, be capable of wanting to murder everyone else which made for a whole host of not nice characters. We all struggled with the characters in someway. We didn't like them. There were too many. They were too self-centered, too two dimensional. Not liking the characters often means we don't like the book and there is no denying it was definitely a hindrance. A few of the group also commented on a plot hole or two. When exactly did

Lock down book club - autobiographies

After what felt like 13 million weeks in lock down we attempted to conduct our first online meeting via Zoom. We chose a broad theme of 'autobiographies' to give as many of us as possible a chance at obtaining a book without too much difficulty. I actually didn't have an autobiography on my shelf and so borrowed The Last American Man by Elizabeth Gilbert. The book was all about raccoon eating, teepee living, deer skin wearing Eustace Conway. He has lived a fascinating life and Gilbert had carried out interviews with a wide range of friends and family but I found the lack of pictures puzzling. You gotta have pictures in an autobiography. The group had chosen autobiographies from a real wide range of people. Partly due to availability, partly due to differing interests. We had Gok Wan and his troubled childhood as a non white gay person. Louis XIV (the Sun King) and his debauched court and two Michelle Obamas one of which was given up on. I think the broad topic made fo