Skip to main content

The Island Victoria Hislop

Despite a hip replacement we still managed a joint best ever 9 members this month including two new ones. I really must take time out to say thank you to Sainsburys for their notice board. Nearly every new member who comes to a meeting mentions the Sainsburys sign, they are one of the few places in Cramlington that allows us to put a sign up and it's free! Hooray for Sainsburys.

Anyway books!

Or perhaps two books as The Island certainly seemed to be a book of two halves. The book starts off with Alexis heading off on holiday complete with imperfect boyfriend and mysterious mother. Chick lit alert! Well I said to myself I can totally guess where this is going, of to Greece where she will meet some handsome hunk and imperfect boyfriend will be kicked to the curb.

Except no, suddenly we were transported to the 1940s where a whole different book emerged, with twists and turns, strong characters, and not a hint of Chick lit in sight. Nearly all of us thought that the Alexis part of the story was superfluous. It didn't add to the book and seemed as though Hislop couldn't think of a way to introduce the story she wanted to write and so copped out with Alexis.

The ending also seemed to dilute the Spinalonga part of the book. It wound the whole story up too quickly and again seemed to (dare I say it) whisper at Chick lit - with mother dropping everything to fly to Greece and after not being able to even mention Greece to her daughter previoulsy confesses all over a Greek salad.

It sounds like I'm slating this book so let me make it clear I'm not. I've even recommended this to friends who haven't previously read it. Why? Because of the Spinalonga part of the book The Island where people diagnosed with leprosy were sent to live leaving everything and everyone they knew behind.

It was in this part that any comparisons to Chick lit got completely blown away and a real vivid picture of Cretian life emerged. It was wonderful to read about Plaka, the roles everyone played in society, how life was back then, their traditions and their amazing fighting spirit - they were quite willing to single handedly fight the Germans when they invaded.

The characters themselves were also really powerful. Anna who everyone in the group wanted to give a good shake, Fontini who you wanted as a friend. I would say that they were a touch one dimensional - Anna from the beginning was trouble and never strayed from this path where Maria was a constant goody two shoes to the point of almost verging on martyrdom.

The description of life on The Island was good. The book passed through 3 generations and you were shown the progression of how The Island prospered from not even having a proper water supply to the point that the inhabitants were better off during the occupation than the actual inhabitants of Spinalonga. They had electricity, decent hospital, food and even movies!

We discussed the horrors of leprosy and how we didn't really know much about it but envisioned hideous disfigured old crones lurking in shadows. One of our group compared leprosy to HIV ie how initially sufferers were shunned, condemned and the misconceptions surrounding the disease where it was thought that merely touching someone would infect you.

For those of you who are interested Spinalonga is an actual place, there was an actual leper colony and you can now go on holiday to Plaka and take a day trip to Spinalonga.

We awarded the book an 8. For a few members it was second time around for this book and it seemed to reread favourably.

Next book is The Hours by Michael Cunningham

PS next month Book Club is one years old. Get the candle ready!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Mount by Jilly Cooper #inbetweeny

I'll start this blog with a warning, this post does contain spoilers. So if you haven't read the book then please don't read this blog, yet. Of course you should read this post just wait a little while until you've read the latest installment of Rupert Campbell Black (RCB). Warnings out of the way I'll begin. I was massively looking forward to reading this book having hugely enjoyed the previous ones. RCB is my (not so) secret trashy pleasure and has been for many years. This book had all the ingredients of a classic, pages of wonderfully named characters, a few tortured souls and of course RCB with all his horses, dogs and now grandchildren. The book got off to a good start full of characters from old but also plenty of new ones to mix it up a bit. The horse's really played a starring role in this book but I also really loved Gav and at first Gala. Yep only at first as she went strongly down hill and I bet you can guess why. RCB. Here is where I fell o...

After The Party by Cressida Connolly

After The Party was May's book of the month. “Had it not been for my weakness, someone who is now dead could still be alive. That is what I believed and consequently lived with every day in prison.’ It is the summer of 1938 and Phyllis Forrester has returned to England after years abroad. Moving into her sister’s grand country house, she soon finds herself entangled in a new world of idealistic beliefs and seemingly innocent friendships. Fevered talk of another war infiltrates their small, privileged circle, giving way to a thrilling solution: a great and charismatic leader, who will restore England to its former glory. At a party hosted by her new friends, Phyllis lets down her guard for a single moment, with devastating consequences. Years later, Phyllis, alone and embittered, recounts the dramatic events which led to her imprisonment and changed the course of her life forever.” We were very confused initially as to which party the book was referring to. We all thought it...

Wedlock by Wendy Moore

Is a book good if you all liked it but can't find much to say about it? That was the case with Wedlock . A true story about Mary Eleanor Bowes ' marriage to Captain Stoney , the violence she suffered at his hand and her subsequent struggle to obtain a divorce in the 1700's. We started off fine, enthusing about how much we all liked it until suddenly we were talking about X Factor. Ahem. This is a serious book club don't you know Ok so lets have a serious conversation about all the local history the book contained. Oh yes we loved the fact that it was all about Newcastle. Didn't it make you want to visit Gibside Hall that is so close to us but that we've never been to. And Bowes Museum, we should have a field trip. Now Peshwari Naan Bread is far superior to Garlic...how did that creep in?! A Chicken Chaat discussion later and we managed to discuss how easy the book was to read. Despite it being a period book there was no archaic language making it very acce...